Loading trail…
Colorado · Fishing
Gypsum sits in the Eagle River valley at the western end of Eagle County, and it punches above its weight as a fishing base camp.
15 spotsUpdated dailyFree to access
View on mapFishing · 15 spots
Gypsum sits in the Eagle River valley at the western end of Eagle County, and it punches above its weight as a fishing base camp. Within reasonable driving distance you have a genuine mix of lake and river fishing — from the high-country stillwater of Island Lakes, East Lost Lake, and Lost Lake to moving-water spots like Cross Creek, Big Fish, and the river sections around the Flat Tops Wilderness. The Flat Tops area alone gives you access to both the northwest drainages and the southeast corner, meaning you can fish different watersheds on different days without retracing the same road twice. Ute-Sweetwater and Bailey Lakes round out the stillwater options if you want a calmer morning on the water. Most of the lake fishing here sits at elevation, so expect short windows of ideal conditions in early summer and again in early fall. River spots like Horse Pasture Site and Lake of the Woods tend to fish more consistently through the summer once runoff settles. This is not a destination built around one marquee fishery — it is a region where knowing which water to hit on a given day, given conditions and season, matters more than showing up with the right fly box.
For the high-elevation lakes like Island Lakes, East Lost Lake, and Lost Lake, late June through early July is typically when ice-out finishes and fish become active near the surface. Early September can also be productive before temperatures drop hard. River spots like Cross Creek and the Flat Tops drainages fish better from mid-July onward once spring runoff clears and water levels stabilize.
Both. The area around Gypsum has a solid split between stillwater and moving water. Lake options include Antones, Bailey Lakes, Hooper Lake, Island Lakes, East Lost Lake, Lost Lake, Dry Lake, and Ute-Sweetwater. River and stream fishing is available at spots like Horse Pasture Site, Big Fish, Cross Creek, Lake of the Woods, and sections within the Flat Tops NW and SE Flat Tops Area.
Lake fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
Lake fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
River fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
River fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
River fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
Lake fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
River fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
Lake fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
River fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
Lake fishing
Gypsum, Colorado
The Flat Tops access trails range from straightforward to moderately strenuous depending on which drainage you target. The fishing itself is not technically demanding — most of the high lakes respond well to basic stillwater techniques with small flies or light spinners. That said, the elevation and remoteness mean you should be comfortable navigating without cell service and prepared for afternoon thunderstorms.
Yes, a valid Colorado fishing license is required for anyone 16 and older. Some waters in and around the Flat Tops Wilderness may carry specific bag limits or gear restrictions set by Colorado Parks and Wildlife, so check the current CPW regulations for Eagle and Garfield counties before you go rather than assuming standard statewide rules apply everywhere.
For the high-elevation lakes, early morning is generally most productive before wind picks up and pushes surface activity down. On the river sections like Cross Creek and Big Fish, early morning and the last two hours before dark tend to see the most consistent action, especially in summer when midday water temperatures rise. Midday fishing in July and August is slower across most of these waters.